law://eu/cjeu/1973/c-158-73/hd_1_1_2_2@2026-11-18The Commission first recalls the general rule under which the deposit is forfeit in proportion to the quantity of goods which could not be imported within the time limit.There are several objections to applying the exceptional procedure provided under Article 18.Force majeure does not in fact apply except in cases where importation within the time limit has been rendered impossible because, for example, the goods have-deteriorated. Article 15, by allowing the interested party to obtain a duplicate but not a second licence equivalent to the original, disposes of the matter conclusively without leaving room for any exception. Otherwise the door would be open to serious speculation as to levies fixed in advance, or even to the ‘loss’ of a licence by a titular holder wishing to avail himself of a circumstance of force majeure.Nevertheless the Commission concedes that the present text of Regulation No 1373/70 is equally open to a less strict interpretation, according to which Article 15 (4) does not absolutely prohibit the application of the exceptional procedure provided for cases of force majeure, and Article 18 does not expressly preclude the loss of the licence being included as a case of force majeure.However, all the conditions necessary for recognizing the existence of force majeure must be fulfilled beyond all possible doubt, according to the definition given in the case law of the Court (Cases 4/68, Firma Schwarzwaldmilch GmbH v Einfuhr und Vorratsstelle für Fette, Rec. 1968, p. 549, and 11/70, Internationale Handelsgesellschaft mbH v Einfuhr und Vorratsstelle für Getreide und Futtermittel, Rec. 1970, p. 1125).The Commission is of the opinion that there should not be force majeure unless ‘abnormal difficulties beyond the importer's control’ have prevented him from effecting the importation within the time limit, and that this circumstance could not ‘be avoided despite all possible care being taken except at excessive cost’ (cases cited).Finally the Commission considers that a request for the recognition of circumstances of force majeure can be submitted even after the period of validity of the licence has expired. In fact, the problem is to determine the maximum period which may be allowed to intervene between the time the obstacle to importation arises and the time the request is submitted, once the titular holder definitely knows he will no longer be able to adhere to the original time limit. This period should be very brief, so that the competent authority can make decisions based on information as recent and as easily verifiable as possible and so that there may be no doubt as to the impossiblity of adhering to the original time limit in order to avoid any speculative action.The Commission suggests the following reply:— the text of Regulation No 1373/70 does not entirely exclude the possibility of investigating whether cases in which loss of the import licence has prevented adherence to the time limit set for importation can be considered as cases of force majeure,— in the absence of any evidence of fraud, the request for recognition of the existence of a case of force majeure may be submitted after the expiry of the period of validity of the import licence.The plaintiffs emphasize that up to the present, within the framework of Article 18, the Court has only had to decide cases in which the inability to effect importation derived from the product itself.Article 18 does not give an exhaustive list of the various circumstances capable of constituting force majeure. The case law of the Court has not limited the concept of force majeure to absolute impossibility. If this case law is applied here, the loss of the licence, in so far as no blame attaches to the importer, also constitutes a case of force majeure.In the plaintiffs' view, the contention that a trader only complies with the duty of care incumbent upon him if he sends the licence by registered post can only be upheld if this is current practice and if dispatch by registered post constitutes a complete safeguard against the loss of the letter.No blame can attach to the plaintiffs' agent for acting in the same way as the competent national authorities, especially since the Court left to the latter the choice of ways and means of dispatch (Case 61/72, Mij PPW internationaal NV v Hoofdproduktschap voor Akkerbouwprodukten, [1973] E.C.R., 301)According to national and international conventions and regulations the purpose and effect of dispatch by registered post is restricted to making available a limited right to claim damages or breach of warranty against the postal authorities in respect of the loss of any letter so dispatched, and to providing proof for those whom it may concern that the letter was sent or received. It follows from this that a registered letter is treated no differently from an ordinary letter in the course of its transit through the post.Finally the plaintiffs stress that it suffices that the authorities be informed of the impossibility of effecting importation, so that they may correct their assessments of market trends and release the deposit. The law providing that a request for extension may be made even after the expiry of the period of validity fixed initially entails as a necessary corollary that a request for cancellation of the obligation to import can also be submitted after the expiry of the period of validity. The request cannot be postponed indefinitely, but this can never be so in a case of loss of the licence, since the request for the issue of a duplicate to evidence imports already effected serves to inform the authorities of the event which entails the extinction of the obligation to import and the release of the deposit.The plaintiffs therefore suggest the following answers to the second question:— the loss of a licence, if independant of fault, is a case of force majeure within the meaning of Article 18;— the importer discharges the duty of care expected of a reasonably diligent trader in the context of his activity within the Community even in a case where he sends a licence through the post by ordinary mail;— the request provided for under Article 18 can be submitted even after the period of validity of the licence has expired.The oral procedure was opened on 27 November 1973.The plaintiffs were represented by Barbara Festge, associate of Dr Fritz Modest, both advocates of the Hamburg bar, and the Commission of the European Communities was represented by its Legal Adviser, Peter Kalbe, acting as agent.The Advocate-General presented his opinion at the hearing on 13 December 1973.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.