law://eu/cjeu/1972/c-31-72/hd_1_1_3_2_2@2026-11-20The applicant argues in this context, as in the case of the calculation of his pension, that the rights of an official cannot be barred by lapse of time.The defendant points out in the first place that the claim does not contain ‘a brief statement of the grounds on which the application is based,’ as required by Article 38 (1) of the Court's Rules of Procedure. Moreover, the movement from grade A 4 to grade A 3 took place pursuant to Article 46 of the EEC-EAEC Staff Regulations, which corresponds to Article 46 of the ECSC Staff Regulations.The applicant replies that his claim on this point must be interpreted, not as a legal action, but as a criticism designed to induce the Court to annul of its own motion a measure which can no longer be attacked. The refusal to bring the applicant's treatment into line with the treatment spontaneously extended by the defendant to other officials, following a new trend in the Court's case law, constitutes a new fact, justifying Court proceedings.The defendant replies that the Court has held constantly that its decisions concern only the parties to the case and do not constitute a new fact for other parties whose position is similar (Judgment of 14 December 1965, 47/65, Kalkuhl, Recueil 1965, 1252; Judgment of 8 July 1965, 49/64, Stipperger, Recueil 1965, 661).The movement from grade A 4 to grade A 3, pursuant to Article 46 of the Staff Regulations, took place in accordance with a criterion which the Court has held to be legitimate in the case of contractual servants who were established when the Staff Regulations came into force Judgment of 15 December 1966, Joined Cases 15/64 and 60/65, Moreau, Recueil 1966, 663).
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.