law://eu/cjeu/1972/c-10-72/hd_1_1_3_2@2026-11-19(c) The applicant makes the point that his dismissal notified by letter of 21 December 1971 and brought to his notice on 17 January 1972, when his probation ended on 31 August 1971, cannot be considered as having taken place within a reasonable period.The Commission's reply is that the decision to dismiss him took place within a reasonable time and, if the applicant did not receive notice of it until 17 January 1972, this was not the Commission's doing.(b) The applicant contends that his rights cf defence had been infringed because the letter of 7 December, dismissing his complaint of 8 November against the end of probation report and informing him of the Commission's intention to take action to dismiss him, did not reach him until 13 December 1971, while he was allowed only until 15 December to submit any possible comments. He draws attention to the fact that the report did not advise dismissal but a three months' extension of probation, and he invokes the judgment in Case No 19/70 (Almini v Commission, Recueil 1971, p. 623).The Commission's reply is that the Staff Regulations do not give a probationer a right to make advance observations on a dismissal measure. The Staff Regulations state expressly in the last sentence of the first paragraph of Article 34 (2) that ‘a probationer whose work has not proved adequate for establishment in his post shall be dismissed’. Moreover the applicant had an opportunity to submit his comments in writing on the end of probation report, the tone of which Mr Amiet had indicated to him from October 1971. Yet he made none. In his reply of 14 December 1971, which could have contained the considerations which he had been able to elaborate from October, the applicant put forward nothing concrete to show that the opinions about him contained in his end of probation report were wrong. The Commission contends that there are some fundamental differences between Case 19/70 and the present cases.(c) The applicant makes the point that there was a misuse of powers: the unfavourable opinion given on him and his dismissal are explained, not by objective grounds connected with the interest of the service, but by the desire to promote Mr Garet, a French official in Grade A 4, to the post to be filled or at any rate to appoint him to it temporarily. Mr Garet had been a candidate for the post to which the applicant was appointed. Mr Garet made an administrative appeal and only after this appeal, ‘undoubtedly in October, 1971’, had there been any question of an unfavourable assessment and the dismissal of the applicant. Since it appeared to the officials of the Commission that Mr Garet's appeal was likely to be completely successful, steps were taken to dismiss the applicant so as, if not to promote Mr Garet, at any rate to give him the post temporarily.The Commission's reply is that these allegations are devoid of any foundation and that the applicant adduces nothing in support of them. In fact, since the applicant's dismissal, Mr Garet was neither given the post in question temporarily nor was he appointed to it; on the contrary the Commission, at its meeting of 24 July 1972, appointed an official of Italian nationality, Mr S. Ventura. In the opinion of the Commission the applicant has not shown that his unfavourable end of probation report was not a sufficient ground to justify his dismissal.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.