law://eu/cjeu/1967/c-6-67/hd_1_1_2@2026-11-18The observations may be summarized as follows:The defendant in the main action considers that an affirmative answer must be given to the question put.Under the terms of Article 1 of Regulation No 3 the expression ‘competent authority’ shall mean in respect of each Member State the Minister, Ministers or other equivalent authority responsible for social security schemes; consequently this expression must be understood to refer to the executive authority in charge of the social security scheme; since in legal theory the Conseil d'État forms part of the executive, it must be considered to be included in the expression ‘authorities’.The defendant in the main action also draws attention to Article 43 (b) of Regulation No 3, which requires the Administrative Commission to carry out all translations relating to the implementation of that Regulation at the request of the competent authorities and agencies of a Member State, and in particular translations of claims submitted by persons who may be entitled to benefit under the Regulation.The Belgian Government is of the same opinion because, as the actual provisions of Regulation No 3 do not provide an express answer to the question put, the solution to the problem posed must be sought elsewhere.(a) On 11 January 1966 the Commission of the EEC submitted to the Council a proposal for the regulation intended to replace Regulation No 3 then in force; Article 67 of the draft which would replace the present Article 45 (4) provides that: ‘The authorities, institutions and courts of one Member State shall not reject claims, or other documents submitted to them, on the grounds that they are written in an official language of another Member State’. The Government wonders whether there is any point in maintaining now that the Conseil d'État may only have applications brought before it in one of the three languages used in Belgium, although this argument will be precluded in the near future.(b) Regulation No 3 was substituted tor Treaty provisions which already provided that migrant workers might use their own language in court proceedings.Thus Article 31 of the Convention concerning social security concluded on 30 April 1948 by Belgium and Italy provided that persons entitled thereunder may apply to the agencies, authorities and courts of the contracting countries in one of the official languages of either of those countries.Although Article 31 does not appear in Annex D to Regulation No 3, it may be considered that, since it made no reservation in the course of the draf ting of Regulation No 3, Belgium thought that this Regulation did not constitute a retreat by comparison with the Convention of 30 April 1948 and that the spirit at least, if not the letter, of the latter was retained.The Commission of the EEC bases its affirmative reply principally on the ratio legis of the Treaty and of the Regulations.The question put is clearly whether courts are referred to by the expressions employed in Article 45 of the Regulation; it merely seeks the interpretation of the term ‘authorities’, since the term ‘institution’ is defined in Article 1 (e) of Regulation No 3 in such a way as to exclude its application to courts.The Commission takes the view that a literal interpretation of the expression ‘authorities’ does not preclude an affirmative response; it puts forward the following arguments:(a) Regulation No 3 does not expressly define the term ‘authorities’ and the definition of the term ‘competent authority’ given by Article 1 (d) of Regulation No 3 is not decisive in resolving whether or not the term ‘authorities’ is applicable to courts.(b) Literally interpreted, the terms ‘autorités’, ‘Behörden’, 'autorità and ‘autoriteiten’ do not have identical scope in all the Community languages.(c) The nature of the documents referred to by Article 45 (4) (claims) does not exclude the interpretation that ‘authorities’ include courts.(d) Article 47 or Regulation No 3, which clearly refers to courts as well as to administrative authorities, speaks of ‘an authority, institution or other agency of that State’. It is not impossible to find a certain difference between Articles 45 and 47 and to consider that courts are included having regard to the fact that in Article 47 the expression ‘other agency’ has been added to authorities and institutions; although this argument does have some force, it must indeed be recognized that the expression in question is one which is rarely used to describe courts.(e) The preparatory studies do not make it possible to conclude with certainty that the authors of the European Convention drawn up under the aegis of the ECSC intended to include courts in the scope of the provisions which were to become Article 45 (4).It appears to emerge from the case-law of the Court that with regard to the interpretation of Regulations Nos 3 and 4 the literal meaning of the provisions is less important than an endeavour to arrive at an interpretation which conforms with the objectives of the Treaty (judgment in Case No 4/66, Labots (nee Hagenbeek)); the decisive argument in favour of an affirmative reply to the question put to the Court must therefore be based on the fact that the clause concerning the use of the languages of the contracting parties, even in relationships between individuals and the courts, has become the accepted style in international conventions on social security.Most of the bilateral Conventions concluded between the Member States contained such a clause which was worded as follows: ‘Communications dealing with social security submitted under the present Convention to agencies, authorities and courts of one of the contracting parties shall be drawn up in one of the official languages of one or other of the contracting parties’.Community regulations replaced the said Conventions under Article 5 (a) of Regulation No 3; Article 6 (2) of the said Regulation allowed the Member States to continue to apply the provisions of conventions previously concluded by registering them in Annex D to that Regulation. None of the clauses on the use of languages was registered in the Annex.It is difficult to imagine chat the Member States concerned intended to withdraw from the migrant workers the enjoyment of a right which had previously been available to them; such an intention would be contrary to the recitals which the Governments of the Member States included in the European Convention.An interpretation based on the silence of the provisions would also be contrary to the views of the Court on the interpretation of Regulations Nos 3 and 4: ‘In case of doubt, Articles 48 to 51 of the Treaty and measures taken in implementation thereof must be construed so as to avoid placing migrant workers in an unfavourable position, particularly with regard to social security’ (judgment in Case 92/63, Nonnenmacher).The Commission moreover notes that the conventions concluded by Member States with third countries often contain the clause on the use of languages. Community workers must not be placed in an unfavourable position in comparison with the advantages conferred in Community countries on migrant workers from third countries.
Source: EUR-Lex, © European Union, 1998-2026. Reuse authorised under Decision 2011/833/EU.